Travis Ishikawa sent the Giants to the National League pennant with his home run of Michael Wacha in Game 5 of the National League championship series.
It conjured up memories of Bobby Thomson’ Shot-Heard-‘Round-The-World in 1951.
But where does it rank among postseason home runs by the San Francisco Giants over the past 25 years.
My Giants fandom is about 40 years old. So I thought back to some of the most memorable postseason home runs the Giants have hit since 1987, their first postseason appearance in 16 years at that time.
I came up with 10. The complete list of blasts is listed at the bottom. So look over these home runs then cast your vote for the most memorable.
Will Clark, grand slam, fourth inning, Game 1 of the 1989 NLCS vs. Chicago
Clark had already hit a solo home run in the third when he came up against in the fourth and the Giants leading 4-3. The Cubs’ Greg Maddux looked as if he might escaped a bases loaded jam when he got Robby Thompson to pop up for the second out. Cubs manager Don Zimmer came out to talk to Maddux. On the on-base cirle with Kevin Mitchell, Clark says he read Maddux’s lips and saw “fastball.” Clark hit the first pitch into the right field bleachers for a grand slam. The Giants went on to win 11-3. And since then, pitchers now cover the mouths with their gloves during conferences on the mound.
Barry Bonds, solo home run, second inning, Game 1 of the 2002 World Series vs. Anaheim
After the Giants went down in order in the first inning, Bonds made the first plate appearance in the World Series in his long career. Instead of pitching around Bonds, as teams had done all season, the Angels’ Jerrod Washburn decided to challenge Bonds. Bonds answered with a long drive into right field that left Washburn shrugging his shoulders. The Giants would go on to win 4-3.
Cody Ross, solo home run, fifth inning, Game 1 of 2010 NLCS vs. Philadelphia
The Giants were facing Roy Halladay, who would go on to win the 2010 NL Cy Young. In his previous start, Hallday became the second pitcher to throw a postseason no-hitter when he beat the Reds. Ross was batting eighth in the lineup (BEHIND Mike Fontenot). He took Halladay deep in the third for the Giants’ first hit of the game. The game was tied 1-1 when Ross came up again in the fifth. He sent a 2-0 pitch over the left-field fence for a 2-1 lead the Giants would not relinquish on way to a 4-3 win.
Juan Uribe, solo home run, eighth inning, Game 6 of the 2010 NLCS vs. Philadelphia
The Giants fell behind early 2-0, but rallied to tie the game in third. Then Jonathan Sanchez got the early hook, and relievers Jeremy Affeldt, Madison Bumgarner, Javier Lopez, Tim Lincecum and Brian Wilson kept the Phillies off the board for seven innings. But the game was still tied until Uribe came up against Ryan Madson with two-out in the eight. Uribe took Madson’s first pitch and sent it over the right-field fence for a home run and a 3-2 lead. That would be the final, and the Giants were off to the World Series.
Edgar Renteria, three-run homer, seventh inning, Game 5 of the 2010 World Series vs. Texas
With the Giants one win from a World Series title, Tim Lincecum and the Rangers’ Cliff Lee put up zeroes for six innings. But in the seventh, Cody Ross and Juan Uribe singled. Aubrey Huff bunted them over, but Pat Burrell struck out. Then Renteria, who spent much of the season on the DL with various injuries, got ahead 2-0, then sent a drive into left-center that cleared the fence for a 3-0 lead. The Giants would go on to win 3-1 for their first World Championship since 1954.
The Giants dropped the first games of the series at home, then found a way to squeak out a 2-1 win in Game 3 on a 10th-inning error. After winning Game 4, they found themselves facing an old nemisis in Mat Latos. The Giants pushed across two runs in the fifth to take a 2-0 lead when the loaded the bases. Posey came up and worked the count to 2-2 before sending the next pitch into the upper deck in left for a 6-0 lead. The Reds rallied back to make it 6-4 before the Giants closed out the series, making Posey’s slam the big hit.
Pablo Sandoval, solo home run, fifth inning, Game 1 of the 2012 World Series vs. Detroit
Sandoval had alredy taken Justin Verlander deep twice — a solo shot to center in the first inning and a two-run poke to left in the third — when he came up against Al Albuquerque in the fifth. Then he joined Babe Ruth, Reggie Jackson and Albert Pujols as the only players to hit three home runs in World Series game when he took Albuquerque out to center.
Brandon Crawford, grand slam, fourth inning, Wild Card Game vs. Pittsburgh
Crawford became the fourth San Francisco Giant to hit a postseason grand slam when he took Edinson Volquez’s 1-2 pitch out to right to give the Giants a 4-0 lead en rout to an 8-0 win in a wild-card elimination game against the Pirates.
Brandon Belt, solo home run, 18th inning, Game 2 of the NLDS vs. Washington
After the Giants rallied in the ninth to score and run and force extra innings and after Yusmeiro Petit’s six shutout innings of relief, Belt led off the 18th and took Tanner Roark’s 3-2 pitch out deep to right. Belt, who missed much of the season with a broken finger and later a concussion, had only recently returned to the lineup to deliver in a big spot. The Giants won 2-1 and took a 2-0 series lead.
Travis Ishikawa, three-run home run, ninth inning, Game 5 of the NLCS vs. St. Louis
Since playing a key reserve role on the 2010 Giants World Series team, Ishikawa had been designated for assignment by the Giants, Orioles, Yankees, White Sox and Pirates. He had bounced around the minors and twice contemplated retirement, even as recently as earlier this summer when languishing at Triple-A Fresno. But injuries led to his call-up in July. Even though he had only played 11 games in the outfield in his big league career, Ishikawa started all but one of the Giants’ postseason games this fall in left field. He misplayed a ball hit by John Jay earlier in the game for the Cardinals’ first run. But ready for redemption when he came up with two on and one out in the ninth of a 3-3 tie. Ishikawa sent Michael Wacha’s 2-0 pitch just over the wall in right for the Giants’ first postseason walk-off home run since Bobby Thomson’s blast in 1951.
All of Giants’ postseason home runs since 1987
1987 NLCS vs. StL
Jeffrey Leonard, Game 1
Will Clark, Game 2
Jeffrey Leonard, Game 2
Jeffrey Leonard, Game 3
Harry Spilman, Game 3
Bob Brenly, Game 4
Jeffrey Leonard, Game 4
Robby Thompson Game 4
Kevin Mitchell, Game 5
1989 NLCS vs. Chi
Will Clark (2), Game 1
Kevin Mitchell, Game 1
Kevin Mitchell, Game 2
Robby Thompson, Game 2
Matt Williams, Game 2
Robby Thompson, Game 3
Matt Williams, Game 4
1989 World Sries vs. Oak
Bill Bathe, Game 3
Matt Williams, Game 3
Greg Litton, Game 4
Kevin Mitchell, Game 4
1987 NLDS vs. Fla
Bill Mueller, Game 1
Brian Johnson, Game 2
Jeff Kent (2), Game 3
2000 NLDS vs. NYM
Ellis Burks, Game 1
J.T. Snow, Game 2
2002 NLDS vs. Atl
Rich Aurilia, Game 2
Barry Bonds, Game 2
JT Snow, Game 2
Barry Bonds, Game 3
Rich Aurilia, Game 4
Barry Bonds, Game 5
2002 NLCS vs. StL
David Bell, Game 1
Kenny Lofton, Game 1
Benito Santiago, Game 1
Rich Aurilia (2), Game 2
Barry Bonds, Game 3
Benito Santiago, Game 4
2002 World Series vs. Ana
Barry Bonds, Game 1
Reggie Sanders, Game 1
JT Snow Game 1
David Bell, Game 2
Barry Bonds, Game 2
Jeff Kent, Game 2
Reggie Sanders, Game 2
Rich Aurilia, Game 3
Barry Bonds, Game 3
Rich Aurilia Game 5
Jeff Kent (2), Game 5
Barry Bonds, Game 6
Shawon Dunston, Game 6
2010 NLDS vs. Atl
Pat Burrell, Game 2
Cody Ross, Game 4
2010 NLCS vs. Phi
Cody Ross (2), Game 1
Cody Ross, Game 2
Juan Uribe, Game 6
2010 World Series vs. Texas
Juan Uribe, Game 1
Edgar Renteria, Game 2
Cody Ross, Game 3
Andres Torres, Game 3
Aubrey Huff, Game 4
Buster Posey, Game 4
Edgar Renteria, Game 5
2012 NLDS vs. Cin
Buster Posey, Game 1
Gregor Blanco, Game 4
Angel Pagan, Game 4
Pablo Sandoval, Game 4
Buster Posey, Game 5
2012 NLCS vs. StL
Angel Pagan, Game 2
Hunter Pence, Game 4
Pablo Sandoval, Game 4
Pablo Sandoval, Game 5
Brandon Belt, Game 7
2012 World Series vs. Det
Pablo Sandoval (3), Game 1
Buster Posey, Game 4
2014 Wild Card vs. Pit
2014 NLDS vs. Was
Brandon Belt, Game 2
Joe Panik, Game 5
Mike Morse, Game 5
Travis Ishikawa, Game 5
Hunter Strickland’s journey to baseball’s biggest stage is an interesting one.
When the Giants called him up in September, some folks were christening Strickland as the Giants’ new “closer of the future,” replacing the recently traded Heath Hembree.
Strickland was big. He threw hard (like 100 mph hard) and he threw strikes.
After a particularly impressive save outing of the 13th inning win over the Dodgers, even Giants closer Santiago Casilla was calling Strickland the Giants’ new closer.
Well, not so fast.
Before we document Strickland’s issue, let’s first look at his past.
Drafted in the 18th round of the 2007 draft, Strickland signed with the Red Sox right out of high school in Georgia.
In his days with the Red Sox, his fastball was reported to top out at 94 mph and be clocked regularly in the upper 80s to low 90s.
He had mixed results as a starting pitcher when he was traded in 2009 to the Pirates, who regarded him as a sleeper prospect.
After never rising abov high A-ball, he missed all of 2011 with shoulder problems.
He returned in 2012 and remained a starter for the Pirates’ A-ball team. He was promoted to Double-A midseason and moved to the bullpen.
He was added to the Pirates’ 40-man roster in November 2012, but designated for assignment at the end of spring training the following March. The Giants claimed him and sent him to Class A San Jose.
He was 1-0 with 0.86 ERA in 20 relief appearances before blowing out his elbow, requiring Tommy John surgery in June. The Giants released him in July, but re-signed him to a minor-league deal in August.
He was back and throwing hard in spring training. He was sent to Double-A Richmond, where he was 1-1 with 2.02 ERA in 35.2 innings with 48 strikeouts and four walks when the Giants called him up in September when rosters expanded.
Now 26, Strickland made nine appearances in September, throwing 7 innings, giving up no runs on five hits with nine strikeouts and no walks. Right-handers hit .200 off him (3 for 15), as did lefties (2 for 10, 2B). However, righties struck out seven times while lefties whiffed just twice.
But in the postseason a serious hole has been exposed in Strickland.
In the postseason, right-handed batters are 1 for 10 with a walk and three strikeouts. Pretty good.
But against left-handers, well….
Lefties are 4 for 7 with four home runs and two strikeouts.
In the playoffs, manager Bruce Bochy has been using Strickland like a new toy, rolling him out in high-stress situations or to pitch a full inning. One of the homers Strickland gave up tied the game. The other, on Sunday night, gave the opponents the lead.
Maybe he needs to take another approach.
On Sunday, Bochy’s options were limited. Having exhausted his two lefties already, he brought in Strickland to face righty Matt Holiday to end the seventh. Strickland picked off Kolten Wong instead.
With the game tied, Bochy didn’t want to his pen again, so he stuck with Strickland. Strickland got Holliday out, then came lefty Matt Adams.
Strickland throws hard, but straight. And this is not Double-A. Big-league hitters can hit anything straight, even if it’s approaching 100 mph.
Against Adams, Strickland made a bad choice or bad pitch.
Unlike against the Nationals’ Bryce Harper, when Strickland fell behind 2-1 and 3-1, Strikland got ahead
Adams 1-2, dropping in a pair of sliders.
Strickland’s next pitch should have been OUT of the strike zone. Up high or outside. Maybe both. Show him the fastball. If he chases, great. If not, you set him up for another slider. If you walk him, big whoop. Go after righties Jhonny Peralta and Tony Cruz.
Instead he shot one straight down the middle, and Adams took him deep (SEE ABOVE PHOTO).
Strickland has to be smarter.
Bochy needs to be smarter.
If the matchup is right, go to Strickland. If not, find another option.
Play to his strengths. This is not the right time for on-the-job training.
The 2014 San Francisco Giants’ motto should be: “Somehow, Someway.”
The Giants’ inexplicable postseason run continued Saturday with a 3-0 win over the St. Louis Cardinals in Game 1 of the National League Championship Series.
The Giants again did not tear the ball of the cover. They did manage eight hits, but here is how they scored their three runs.
- A ducksnort bloop single off the Magic Wandoo of Travis Ishikawa.
- An error.
- A sacrifice fly.
And the Giants’ two-run “rally” in the second inning was started on a double by Pablo Sandoval that originally landed in the glove of Cardinals right fielder Randal Grichuk, but popped out after Grichuk hit the wall and then the ground.
The Giants’ third-inning run was aided when second baseman Kolten Wong failed to cleanly field a potential double-play ball off the bat of Hunter Pence. The Cardinals only got one out on the play, so no error, but it made Brandon Belt’s subsequent sacrifice fly possible.
This follows the Giants’ final four runs scored in the Division Series against the Nationals, which were scored on …
- A wild pitch.
- A groundout.
- A walk.
- A sacrifice fly.
The Giants even caught a break when Madison Bumgarner appeared to balk in a run in the seventh inning. But the umpires didn’t call a balk, probably because only the Giants are allowed to score a run on a balk.
It’s hard to figure.
The Giants went 15-61 in games in which they scored three runs or fewer. They were 73-13 when scoring four runs or more, second best in the NL this season (The Nationals had the best mark).
From June 3 to Aug. 25, the Giants went 1-35 in games in which they scored three runs or fewer.
But in the postseason, the Giants are now 4-1 in games in which they score three runs or fewer.
They have scored 12 runs total in their last five postseason games. Yet they find themselves with a 1-0 lead in the NLCS.
After going 5 for 40 (.125) with runners in scoring position in the series with the Nationals, the Giants added a 2-for-11 night with RISP on Saturday. And one of those hits didn’t score a run.
But here’s one stat to note. In the Division Series, the Giants struck out the fewest times of the four NL teams in the LDS round. And it’s not even close. The Nationals struck out 39 times in 172 plate appearances, the Cardinals struck out 37 times in 138 PAs, the Dodgers stuck out 36 times in 155 PAs and the Giants struck out 24 in 175 PAs.
And as the old adage goes “Good things happen when you put the ball in play.”
The other stat is the more obvious one: the pitching.
Giants pitching has an 1.14 ERA in the postseason.
The starting pitching has been even better: 0.64 ERA.
At some point, you have to expect the Giants bats to come alive.
Perhaps that will come in Game 2 on Sunday.
The San Francisco Giants are back in the postseason, for the third time in five years.
Now I’ve been a Giants fan for 40 years. And this is only the second tim in that four-decade span that the Giants have made the postseason three times in five years (they made it three times in four years in 2000, 2002 and 2003).
And yet, there are a lot of Giants who are not excited about the fact the Giants are in the postseason. Not sure why.
Maybe it’s because the Giants didn’t win the NL West.
Maybe it’s because making the playoffs just means a one-game elimination situation.
Maybe it’s because the Giants blew a 9.5-game division lead.
Maybe it’s because the Giants were SOOOOO bad in June and July.
Maybe it’s because the Giants didn’t clinch a playoff berth by winning a game. Instead, they clinched because of a Brewers loss that followed five Giants losses over six games.
Maybe it’s because injuries have left the Giants’ prospects in the postseason so tenuous.
Who know. But really, I think that some Giant fans need a fresh prospective.
Let’s think back to spring training in March. What would you think of the Giants’ chances of making the postseason if the following things came true?
- Matt Cain’s season would be over by the All-Star break.
- Tim Lincecum’s final start would happen on Aug. 23.
- Angel Pagan would spend two months on the DL and be limited to 96 games.
- Marco Scutaro would be a non-factor in 2014.
- Brandon Belt would miss 102 games and hit .241 in the games he did play in.
- Michael Morse would hit just two home runs after the All-Star break and miss nearly the entire month of September.
- Sergio Romo would lose his closer’s job in June and never regain it.
- Brandon Crawford would make a career-high 21 errors.
- The only player the Giants would acquire by trade is a pitcher who was 1-9 with 4.72 ERA.
Given those facts, what would you have thought the Giants would have finished in 2014.
76-86? (Last year’s record).
81-81? I would think that a winning season would have been considered a stretch, given the above facts.
Yet, despite ALL of those hurdles, the Giants finished 88-74 and they are in the playoffs, sending their best pitcher to the mound to win an elimination game.
We’ll remind you the Giants won six consecutive elimination games on their way to the 2012 world championship.
So while there may be a lot of reasons to think the Giants won’t go far this October, there is really one reason to think they will.
They’re the Giants.
And if you need another reason to believe that, well, go root for the A’s.
No matter what White Sox — or Andrew Baggarly — say, San Francisco Giants did not beat Chicago White Sox on a ‘technicality’
During last offseason, Major League Baseball wanted to implement a rule that would prevent home-plate collisions. The rule would be simple and straightforward.
The catcher is not allowed to block the plate. The runner is not allowed to blow up the catcher. The only time home-plate collisions would happen was when the flight of the ball drew the catcher into the runner’s path, making any collision accidental and unavoidable.
But that wasn’t good enough for old-school catchers and managers. They said “How can we teach our catchers how not to block the plate in just six weeks of spring training when that’s how they’ve been playing the position forever (forever meaning in their pro careers, because blocking the plate was not part of the game they played in Little League, high school or college)?”
So MLB waffled a bit, adding a line into the new rule that catchers could still block the plate, if they had possession of the ball. And a can of worms was opened.
Given that sliver of light, old-school managers did not worry about teaching their catchers about where best to position themselves to be in compliance with the new rule. They simply told their catchers to play the position as they have always played it, and make MLB rule that they were doing it incorrectly.
In the first half of the season, MLB gave catchers the benefit of the doubt. The onus was on the runner to avoid contact. Catchers kept blocking the plate like they always had.
But then runners started to complain. Was there a new rule or wasn’t there one? And MLB started to listen. So after the All-Star break, we started to see a swing in how these plays were being ruled on replay.
If the catcher was in the runners path without the ball and didn’t give the runner a path to the plate, the runner would be ruled safe. It didn’t matter how far ahead of the runner that the ball arrived to the plate.
In short, if teams weren’t going to get their catchers to position themselves correctly in compliance with the new rule, MLB was going to do it for them.
And if you’re on the wrong end of one of these calls, you don’t like it. Just like White Sox manager Robin Ventura found himself in when umpires overturned a call in which the Giants’ Gregor Blanco was thrown out at the plate in the seventh inning on Tuesday.
The play resulted in a 1-1 tie, and the Giants went on to score six more times in the inning en route to a 7-1 win. And Ventura was livid.
“You look at the spirit of the rule of what they’re trying to do and what it’s actually doing, and it’s a joke,” said Ventura, who was ejected for arguing and kicking dirt on the plate after a review that lasted nearly five minutes. “We obviously disagreed with it, and we got hosed today.”
Ventura continued: “They don’t take into consideration that the guy was out by a longshot.”
Whoa! Whoa! Whoa! At what point did Ventura start to disagree with this rule. If you rewind back to Tuesday night’s game, Ventura found himself on the opposite end of a similar play.
In the 10th inning, Chicago’s Jordan Danks were ruled out at the plate on a tag by Buster Posey. Ventura came out to have the play to review to see if Posey blocked Danks’ path to the plate, even though Danks was out by a longshot.
One problem, however. The review showed that Posey didn’t block the plate, that he did leave Danks a pathway to the plate.
And why is this? Well, it’s because that’s how the Giants have taught their catchers to position themselves on plays on the plate. They instruct their catchers to get out IN FRONT OF home plate, between home plate and the pitchers mound, field the throw, then apply a sweep tag. That’s what Posey did.
Now fast-forward to Wednesday afternoon. White Sox catcher Tyler Flowers did not get out in front of home plate. He stood right over it. And when he went to field the throw from first baseman Jose Abreu, Flowers left leg clearly blocked off the entire plate from the oncoming Blanco. Flowers even admitted this much, but said that’s not the point.
Except it IS the point.
Some have said the Giants won Wednesday on a “technicality” including CSN Bay Area’s Andrew Baggarly, who called the ruling “lasso-sized legal loophole.”
This is what Flowers said: “I don’t think anybody has an understanding of this rule,. That’s not the purpose of this rule. The purpose of this rule is to prevent a situation like Posey had. It’s not when a guy is out by 30 feet. ‘Oh, he blocked the plate?’ That had no impact on him being safe or out. And there’s no clarification on that.”
There. Flowers just proved my point, even if he didn’t intend to, when he said “this rule is to prevent a situation like Posey had. It’s not when a guy is out by 30 feet.”
Flowers was referring to the Scott Cousins play — I call it the Cousins play because the responsibility for that collision was completely on Cousins — that prematurely Posey’s season in May 2011.
Here are three irrefutable points about the Cousins/Posey play.
- Posey was NOT blocking the plate on that play.
- Posey DID leave Cousins a lane to the plate.
- Cousins did believe he would be out by 30 feet. He felt that from where right fielder Nate Schierholtz was throwing the ball, Cousins would be out easily. His only recourse was to try to dislodge the ball from Posey. As it turned out, Posey got caught with a short hop that he didn’t handle cleanly.
And that’s the point of the new rule. MLB wants catchers to leave runners a lane, so they don’t feel like their only course of action is collide with the catcher. And leaving a lane is all determined by where the catcher sets up to receive the throw.
So here’s another question for Flowers. If Blanco was going to be out by a longshot, why was Flowers even blocking the plate in the first place?
“I had two seconds to get from behind home plate to catch (and) make a tag, and I’m supposed to be able to make sure I don’t block the plate, catch the ball and make the tag, all within two seconds on an infield dribbler?” Flowers said. “That’s not realistic. That play doesn’t make any sense.”
But it is realistic, if it’s a play that you have been trained on doing correctly. Buster Posey had time to do it correctly Tuesday night because he’s been trained to do that. Flowers, likely because the White Sox have not made it a priority, appeared as if he hasn’t been trained on this.
So MLB gave him, and the White Sox, a valuable lesson. And they got what they deserved.
And that’s not a technicality.
When Matt Duffy and Jarrett Parker were told Thursday not to board the Richmond Flying Squirrels team bus for Altoona, they thought that they had been traded as part of a deadline deal.
That would be completely logical.
Instead, both Class AA players were getting promoted to the San Francisco Giants.
The Giants made no deadline deals Thursday to go with the acquisition of Jake Peavy. Instead, the Giants will make a playoff push with the players they have.
That started Friday, when Duffy, an infielder, and Parker, an outfielder, were called up to fill the roster spots vacated when second baseman Dan Uggla and outfielder Tyler Colvin were designated for assignment.
It was the first time since August of 2011 that the Giants have promoted a player midseason from Double-A. Back then it was pitcher Erik Surkamp.
A position player had not been called up from Double-A since Darren Ford earned a September call-up in 2010 as used strictly as a pinch-runner and defender.
The Giants are expecting Duffy and Parker to contribute more than that.
As for Duffy, the move is intriguing. Duffy, drafted as a shortstop, was an 18th-round pick out of Long Beach State in 2012. He has hit at every level: .247/.361 OBP in shortseason A Salem-Keizer in 2012, .307/.405 for Low-A Augusta in 2013, .292/.342 in high-A San Jose in 2013.
He’s hitting .332 with .398 OBP for Double-A Richmond in a pitcher-friendly Eastern League. He led Richmond in hitting by a long shot. And through his minor-league career, he’s walked about as much as he has struck out.
Jarrett Parker is another story. Parker, a second-round pick in 2010, has struggled at the start of every season in the minors, then recovered toward respectability. He hit .253 for San Jose in 2011, .247 for San Jose in 2012, .245 for Richmond in 2013 and .275 with 12 HRs and 58 RBI in 99 games for Richmond this year.
But he’s a big-time swing-and-miss guy: 144 Ks in 127 games in 2011, 175 Ks in 122 games in 2012, 161 Ks in 131 games in 2013, and 103 Ks already in 99 games in 2014.
But he may not be with the club for long. Brandon Belt is expected to be activated from the seven-day concussion disabled list this weekend. When that happens, look for Parker to return to Richmond.
Even if the Giants opt to jettison Travis Ishikawa when Belt returns, look to Parker to get a return bus trip to Richmond by next week when Angel Pagan is expected back from the DL.
Pagan played in an Arizona Rookie League game Friday night, and looked good. Barring setbacks, Pagan could return to the Giants when they arrive in Milwaukee on Tuesday.
But Duffy, as one of two middle infield reserves — along with Joaquin Arias — figures to stick around longer. At least until Ehire Adrianza comes off the disabled list. But that likely won’t happen until the Giants return from this 10-game road trip.
As for Uggla and Colvin, their stints with the Giants may not be over. If both players clear waivers, and they should (Uggla for sure), they could be sent to Fresno, if they accept the assignment.
The Associated Press reported Saturday that the San Francisco Giants are finalizing a deal to bring veteran pitcher Jake Peavy to the Giants.
Details are still being worked out, according to the report. But the Red Sox will reportedly get minor league pitchers Heath Hembree and Edwin Escobar.
The details being worked out likely involve money and other provisions. Peavy is making $14.5 million this season with the Red Sox, meaning he is still owed about $6 million. He has a player option of $15 million for 2015, but he is unlikely to reach the milestones to make that option vest. He would basically have to double his current innings output of 124 innings this season to allow that option to kick in.
Normally when Giants GM Brian Sabaen makes these midseason deals, I reserved judgment, preferring to defer to his better judgment.
The Giants have made several midseason deals over the past few years. Not all of the deals have worked out as the Giants hoped, but at least the Giants didn’t have to give up much to get them.
I wrote about this earlier, listing the prospects the Giants have given up in midseason deals the past five years. Really, only Zack Wheeler has amounted to anything, and the jury is still out on him.
But I’m going to say now that I don’t like this deal. To me, it represents of harbinger of bad news.
And here’s why.
CAIN SITUATION MUST BE BAD: When Matt Cain went on the disabled list after the All-Star break, manager Bruce Bochy said Cain could be down “one week, two weeks …. eight weeks. We just don’t know.” The Giants have been cagy with health reports of their players. So when they say they don’t know, we have to conclude they at least suspect. And the consumation of this deal must indicate they suspect that Cain may not return this season.
THE PRICE WAS TOO HIGH: In giving up Escobar and Hembree, the Giants parted with their No. 2 and No. 11 prospects, according to MLB.com’s preseason list of prospects. Both pitchers have appeared to be on the fast track to the majors in recent spring trainings. Escobar, 22, was thought to be in position to get a call-up this season, but he’s had a rough season in Triple-A. He’s 3-8 with 5.11 ERA and 96 strikeouts in 111 innings at Fresno. Hembree, 25, was thought to be the Giants “closer of the future” a couple of springs ago. But this season represents his third at the Triple-A level. He is 1-3 with 3.89 ERA, 18 saves and 46 strikeouts in 39.1 innings this season with Fresno. He was recently named a PCL All-Star. He did have a brief stint with the Giants in 2013, throwing 7.2 scoreless innings with 12 strikeouts. So I might have been OK giving up one of these two pitchers, along with some lower-level prospects, for Peavy. But giving up both?
THIS AIN’T THE SAME JAKE PEAVY: This has not been a good season for Peavy, 33, in Boston. He’s 1-9 with 4.72 ERA in 20 starts. He leads the American League in home runs allowed with 20. Here are most stats for 2014 to sample
- His ERA+ of 83 is the lowest of his big-league career.
His FIP (Fielding Independent Pitching) of 4.81 is his highest since his second big-league season in 2003 when he was 22.
His WHIP of 1.427 is the highest of his career.
His Hit Allowed Rate of 9.5 is the second highest of his career.
His HR Allowed Rate of 1.5 is the highest of his career.
His Walk Rate of 3.3 is his highest since 2002.
His Strikeout Rate of 7.3 is his lowest since 2002.
Looking for good news?
The Giants are clearly hoping that a return to the National League, where he hasn’t pitched since 2009, will do Peavy good. His four starts against NL teams this season have all been quality starts.
They are also hoping that pitching in AT&T Park will provide better results than pitching in Fenway.
Well, Peavy is 14-2 with 2.21 ERA against the Dodgers in his career also looked good to the Giants. Although it should be pointed out that most of those starts occurred in 2009 or earlier when Peavy was a different pitcher and the Dodgers were a different team. Peavy did limit the Dodgers to one run on three hits in a complete game win in Dodger Stadium last August.
And for good news, Peavy make be on the mound when the Giants face the Dodgers on Sunday night, instead of Yusmeiro Petit.
As the Giants consider making a midseason season trade to bolster the run toward the 2014 playoffs, it might be a good idea to look at what happened to the prospects the Giants traded away in midseason deals over the past five years.
2009 Tim Alderson (for Freddy Sanchez)
Alderson was the Giants’ No. 2 pitching prospect (behind Madison Bumgarner) when he was traded to the Pirates for Freddy Sanchez. Alderson never made it to the big leagues and was traded to the Orioles organization in July 2013. He was 2-4 with 6.12 ERA for the O’s Triple-A affiliate this season before being released. He signed with the A’s and is currently pitching in Class A Stockton.
2010 Joe Martinez and John Bowker (Javier Lopez)
Martinez, a decent long reliever/spot starter with the Giants, made five appearances with the Pirates in 2010. He spent most of the next three seasons in the minors with the Pirates, Diamondbacks and Indians. He was 0-3 with 16.36 ERA with the Angels’ Triple-A team before retiring this April at age 31. Bowker played for the Pirates’ Triple-A team after being acquired in the trade and earned a September call-up. He made the Pirates 2011 roster as a reserve, but spent most of the season in the minors before being traded to the Phillies late that season. In 2012, he went to play in Japan.
2010 Dan Turpen (Ramon Ramirez)
Turpen, a reliever never, made it out of the minors, first with the Red Sox, then Rockies and currently Twins. He’s pitching for the Twins’ Double-A team.
2010 Evan Crawford (Mike Fontenot)
An outfielder, Crawford never made it above Class A ball. He’s currently playing Independent ball in the Frontier League.
2011 Henry Sosa, Jason Stoffel (Jeff Keppinger)
Sosa made a brief appearance with the Astros in 2011. He was later released and signed with the Dodgers this season. He is 1-2 with 3.72 ERA in seven starts for Triple-A Albuquerque. Stoffel, a reliever, is still in the Astros’ system. He’s 2-3 with 2.91 ERA this season for Triple-A Oklahoma City.
2011 Thomas Neal (Orlando Cabrera)
Neal, an outfielder, spent 2011 and most of 2012 in the minors before earning a September callup from the Indians. He was released in January 2013 and signed with the Yankees, earning a couple of brief promotions in June and July of 2013. The Cubs claimed him off waivers in August of that year. He signed a minor-league deal with the Reds in 2014. He’s hitting .254 in 80 games for the Reds’ Triple-A team.
2011 Zack Wheeler (Carlos Beltran)
The former No. 6 overall pick in the 2009 draft, Wheeler was the Giants’ top prospect when he was dealt to the Mets for Beltran. Wheeler was promoted in 2013, going 7-5 with 3.42 ERA in 17 starts. He is 5-8 with 3.78 ERA in 20 starts this season for the Mets.
2012 Charlie Culberson (Marco Scutaro)
Culberson has bounced back-and-forth between the Rockies and Triple-A since being acquired. He is hitting .188 with 2 HR and 12 RBI in 61 games for the Rockies this season.
2012 Nate Schierholtz, Tommy Joseph, Seth Rosin (Hunter Pence)
Schierholtz hit .273 with 1 HR and 5 RBI for the Phillies after the trade in 2012. He signed as a free agent with the Cubs in 2013, hitting 21 HRs, 68 RBI and .251. He had 5 HR, 31 RBI and is hitting .199 this season for the Cubs. Joseph, a catcher, was the key piece in the Pence deal. But he has not realized his potential yet as concussion injuries have slowed his progress. He hit .209 in 21 games for Triple-A Leigh Valley last year. He’s hitting .282 in 21 games for Double-A Reading this season. Rosin pitched 2013 in Double-A before being taken by the Mets in 2013 Rule 5 Draft and traded to the Dodgers. He was on the Dodgers’ opening day roster, but never appeared in a game before being claimed off waivers by the Rangers in late March. He pitched in three games before being DFA’d by the Rangers in April and returned to the Phillies. He is 2-5 with a 4.46 ERA as a reliever for the Philles’ Double-A and Triple-A teams this season.
We’re past the All-Star break. Time to start talking about magic numbers, right?
OK, maybe not. But there is a magic number for the Giants and winning baseball games … at least in the past month.
That the number of runs you have to hope the Giants score tonight against the Phillies. Or any night for that matter.
Since June 20, the Giants are 11-0 when they score four runs or more in a game.
When they don’t, they are 0-15.
Not an earth-shattering stat exactly.
For the season, the Giants are 40-10 when they score 4 or more runs in a game, and 10-34 when they do not.
But here’s one stat that I thought was interesting.
When opponents score two runs in a game, exactly two runs, the Giants this season are 8-9.
EIGHT AND NINE when the opponent scores just two runs.
Not like you had to explain that stat to Matt Cain or Ryan Vogelsong.
As the post All-Star break began, San Francisco Giants fans were lifted with some hope.
The Giants had a modest three-game winning streak. It appeared they were starting to get healthy with the return of Brandon Belt and Marco Scutaro.
But then the reality of Monday hit like a rock.
The Giants placed Matt Cain on the disabled list for the third time this season. And it felt very similar to his first two trips.
Before the All-Star break, Cain was reshuffled in the rotation to the No. 5 spot. Manager Bruce Bochy said, at the time, there was no specific reason for this and that the Giants just wanted to give Cain more time.
Then came news Friday of Cain’s “cranky elbow,” but that he was still expected to start Tuesday against the Phillies.
Then came news of his third DL stint on Monday with elbow inflammation. Cain is eligible to return from the DL Sunday against the Dodgers, but at this point it looks very doubtful.
It was like deja vu from his first two stints, first with a finger laceration and later with a hamstring strain. First reports said “yeah, he’ll be OK and make his next start” followed by “DL time.”
So Yusmeiro Petit gets the call again to fill in for Cain.
On the surface, you can say Petit’s 3-3 record and 3.86 ERA this season is better than Cain’s 2-7 mark and 4.18 ERA. But then you look at Petit’s relief/start splits.
He’s 2-1 with 2.45 ERA in relief and 1-2 with a 5.81 ERA in his five starts.
George Kontos, who has been pitching very well lately in Fresno, gets the call to fill Cain’s roster spot.
Then came news that Belt would be placed on the seven-day concussion DL. Belt was hit in the face with a thrown ball during batting practice on Saturday. Belt was looking to receive a throw from shortstop when another one came in from second base.
Belt started the game Saturday and came out of the game with dizziness. He’ll be eligible to return on Sunday vs. the Dodgers.
Adam Duvall got the call to fill Belt’s roster spot. Duvall, who got called up in June, has hit 3 HRs, 11 RBI and .310 in his last 10 games with Fresno.
And, finally, the Giants took a flyer on veteran second baseman Dan Uggla.
When Uggla was released by the Braves last week, several Giants fans on Twitter was screaming for the Giants NOT to sign him. They compared him to Brandon Hicks, except older and not nearly as good a fielder.
But given their options at second base, it’s a no-risk move to sign Uggla to a minor-league deal and send him to Fresno in an effort to find his stroke.
Uggla has an Aug. 1 opt-out date. That means if he hasn’t been called up to the Giants by then, he can opt-out of his deal and find a better one somewhere else.
It gives the Giants about 10 days to see if Uggla can help.
The best-case scenario is that the Giants catch a little lightning-in-a-bottle with Uggla, similar to what they did in 2010 with Pat Burrell and Cody Ross.
At worst, Uggla spends 10 days in Fresno. That should be long enough.
Everyone hits in Fresno. Juan Perez is hitting .337 in Fresno. Hicks is hitting .333 since he got sent to Fresno.
If in 10 days Uggla isn’t hitting in Fresno, let him take his opt-out.